• About
  • Our Team
  • Advertise
  • Legal
  • Contact Us
Write for Us
Shout Out UK
  • Politics
    • All
    • Brexit 2016
    • Elections
    • GE2017
    • Law
    Is Catalonia entitled to independence ?

    Three million drug addicts in the Philippines: The real Narcos Netflix didn’t cover

    Is Catalonia entitled to independence ?

    Legal aid declines by 84% leaving the most vulnerable without justice

    Is Catalonia entitled to independence ?

    Why the Commonwealth matters more than ever

    Is Catalonia entitled to independence ?

    Democracy Dashboard: The missing piece British politics desperately needs

    Is Catalonia entitled to independence ?

    Campaigning for equal rights in ALL Commonwealth countries

    Is Catalonia entitled to independence ?

    Cold War II: Will McCarthyism repeat itself or will we heed the past?

    Trending Tags

    • Young People
    • Wikileaks
    • Women
    • Welfare
    • Theresa May
  • World News
    • All
    • Africa
    • Asia
    • Australia
    • Europe
    • N. America
    • S. America
    • United Kingdom
    Is Catalonia entitled to independence ?

    Maternity Leave: What really explains the gender pay gap

    Is Catalonia entitled to independence ?

    Why Do Financially Savvy People Avoid Going It Alone?

    Is Catalonia entitled to independence ?

    Three million drug addicts in the Philippines: The real Narcos Netflix didn’t cover

    Is Catalonia entitled to independence ?

    Smart Ways To Grow Your Income Rapidly

    Is Catalonia entitled to independence ?

    Legal aid declines by 84% leaving the most vulnerable without justice

    Is Catalonia entitled to independence ?

    Why the Commonwealth matters more than ever

    Trending Tags

    • West
    • USA
    • Syria
    • US presidential election
    • Terrorism
  • Money
    • All
    • Business
    Is Catalonia entitled to independence ?

    Maternity Leave: What really explains the gender pay gap

    Is Catalonia entitled to independence ?

    Why Do Financially Savvy People Avoid Going It Alone?

    Is Catalonia entitled to independence ?

    Smart Ways To Grow Your Income Rapidly

    Is Catalonia entitled to independence ?

    Home Time: 4 Ways To Make Life Easier When You Get Home From Work

    Is Catalonia entitled to independence ?

    Your Team Productivity Starts In The Workplace

    Is Catalonia entitled to independence ?

    The Formula For Business Success: Professionalism+Productivity=Profitability

    Trending Tags

    • Advice
    • University
    • Unemployment
    • Technology
  • Culture, Travel and Sport
    • All
    • Environment
    • Health
    • Media
    Is Catalonia entitled to independence ?

    How Doing Yoga Every Day Can Help Ease Your Body Aches

    Is Catalonia entitled to independence ?

    Making Time For Inner Quiet Is Important

    Is Catalonia entitled to independence ?

    We’re Ready For Summer! But Are Our Eyes Ready For The Sun?

    Is Catalonia entitled to independence ?

    Comedians Roisin and Chiara on International Women’s Day

    Is Catalonia entitled to independence ?

    The Button Poets: Changing the world one verse at a time

    Is Catalonia entitled to independence ?

    In The Net: Why England’s Women Are So Psyched For Commonwealth Success

    Trending Tags

    • Motorsport
    • Cars
    • Travel
    • Food
    • Music
  • Reviews
    Is Catalonia entitled to independence ?

    Upstart Crow, Upstart No: Not a comedy but an outdated tragedy

    Is Catalonia entitled to independence ?

    Philosophers’ Club: Irrational Man – Freedom in the Extreme

    Is Catalonia entitled to independence ?

    Book Club: Woman at Point Zero

    Is Catalonia entitled to independence ?

    Philosophers’ Club: The Revenant – Grisly but Unique

    Is Catalonia entitled to independence ?

    Video Game Review: WWE 2K16

  • Films
    • Homelessness
    • Anonymous
    • Youth Leaders
    • Mental Health
    • One in a Million
  • Political Literacy
    • Offline Course
    • Online Course
    • Election Pack
  • Get Involved
    • Write for us
    • Opportunities
    • Brexit Youth Check
    • Events
No Result
View All Result
  • Politics
    • All
    • Brexit 2016
    • Elections
    • GE2017
    • Law
    Is Catalonia entitled to independence ?

    Three million drug addicts in the Philippines: The real Narcos Netflix didn’t cover

    Is Catalonia entitled to independence ?

    Legal aid declines by 84% leaving the most vulnerable without justice

    Is Catalonia entitled to independence ?

    Why the Commonwealth matters more than ever

    Is Catalonia entitled to independence ?

    Democracy Dashboard: The missing piece British politics desperately needs

    Is Catalonia entitled to independence ?

    Campaigning for equal rights in ALL Commonwealth countries

    Is Catalonia entitled to independence ?

    Cold War II: Will McCarthyism repeat itself or will we heed the past?

    Trending Tags

    • Young People
    • Wikileaks
    • Women
    • Welfare
    • Theresa May
  • World News
    • All
    • Africa
    • Asia
    • Australia
    • Europe
    • N. America
    • S. America
    • United Kingdom
    Is Catalonia entitled to independence ?

    Maternity Leave: What really explains the gender pay gap

    Is Catalonia entitled to independence ?

    Why Do Financially Savvy People Avoid Going It Alone?

    Is Catalonia entitled to independence ?

    Three million drug addicts in the Philippines: The real Narcos Netflix didn’t cover

    Is Catalonia entitled to independence ?

    Smart Ways To Grow Your Income Rapidly

    Is Catalonia entitled to independence ?

    Legal aid declines by 84% leaving the most vulnerable without justice

    Is Catalonia entitled to independence ?

    Why the Commonwealth matters more than ever

    Trending Tags

    • West
    • USA
    • Syria
    • US presidential election
    • Terrorism
  • Money
    • All
    • Business
    Is Catalonia entitled to independence ?

    Maternity Leave: What really explains the gender pay gap

    Is Catalonia entitled to independence ?

    Why Do Financially Savvy People Avoid Going It Alone?

    Is Catalonia entitled to independence ?

    Smart Ways To Grow Your Income Rapidly

    Is Catalonia entitled to independence ?

    Home Time: 4 Ways To Make Life Easier When You Get Home From Work

    Is Catalonia entitled to independence ?

    Your Team Productivity Starts In The Workplace

    Is Catalonia entitled to independence ?

    The Formula For Business Success: Professionalism+Productivity=Profitability

    Trending Tags

    • Advice
    • University
    • Unemployment
    • Technology
  • Culture, Travel and Sport
    • All
    • Environment
    • Health
    • Media
    Is Catalonia entitled to independence ?

    How Doing Yoga Every Day Can Help Ease Your Body Aches

    Is Catalonia entitled to independence ?

    Making Time For Inner Quiet Is Important

    Is Catalonia entitled to independence ?

    We’re Ready For Summer! But Are Our Eyes Ready For The Sun?

    Is Catalonia entitled to independence ?

    Comedians Roisin and Chiara on International Women’s Day

    Is Catalonia entitled to independence ?

    The Button Poets: Changing the world one verse at a time

    Is Catalonia entitled to independence ?

    In The Net: Why England’s Women Are So Psyched For Commonwealth Success

    Trending Tags

    • Motorsport
    • Cars
    • Travel
    • Food
    • Music
  • Reviews
    Is Catalonia entitled to independence ?

    Upstart Crow, Upstart No: Not a comedy but an outdated tragedy

    Is Catalonia entitled to independence ?

    Philosophers’ Club: Irrational Man – Freedom in the Extreme

    Is Catalonia entitled to independence ?

    Book Club: Woman at Point Zero

    Is Catalonia entitled to independence ?

    Philosophers’ Club: The Revenant – Grisly but Unique

    Is Catalonia entitled to independence ?

    Video Game Review: WWE 2K16

  • Films
    • Homelessness
    • Anonymous
    • Youth Leaders
    • Mental Health
    • One in a Million
  • Political Literacy
    • Offline Course
    • Online Course
    • Election Pack
  • Get Involved
    • Write for us
    • Opportunities
    • Brexit Youth Check
    • Events
No Result
View All Result
Shout Out UK
No Result
View All Result
Home World News Europe

Is Catalonia entitled to independence ?

Shout Out UK by Shout Out UK
03/10/2012
0
0
SHARES
Share on FacebookShare on Twitter

Is Catalonia entitled to independence ?

An unprecedented 1.5 millions people march in the streets of Barcelona this 11th September proved that the economic crisis hitting Spain has fuelled Catalan separatism. Indeed many Catalans, report Euronews, blame the government in Madrid for dragging down Spain’s most prosperous region.

The one of Catalonian secession is an issue that has been prominent since a long time, but has become even more relevant. In the Catalan Elections of 2010 pro-independence parties gathered 11,6% of the votes, becoming able to influence the political agenda of the Catalan government. At the same time a certain number of unofficial referendums (consultes populars) on independence held since September 2009 have expressed a widespread support for secession.
All this suggests not only that separatism is on the rise, but also that the possibility of a secession from Spain in the future must not be completely ruled out.
This said, is Catalonia entitled to independence ? Such is the question that this article will be trying to answer and this will be done by looking at the idea of self-determination and its relation to the states’ right to territorial integrity in international law.

Secessionist demands rely on the claim that a central government is impeding national self-determination, defined as “the right of all peoples to freely determinate their political status and freely pursue their economic, social and cultural development” (Resolution 1514 of the United Nations General Assembly). The idea of self-determination is today enshrined in the United Nations’ Charter and both the International Covenants of 1966. Other documents setting what international law says on self-determination are the already mentioned Resolution 1514 and Resolution 2625 of the United Nations General Assembly. These instruments affirm that the self-determination of peoples in one of the UN’s goals and that it is a legal right enjoyed by all peoples. If all of this seems to support secessionist movements around the world, Resolution 2625 also adds that states conducting themselves in compliance with international law and possessing a truly representative government enjoy a right to territorial integrity.

The self-determination of people indeed coexists with this other principle of territorial integrity of states, which is at the base of today’s international system. That a state’s territorial integrity is inviolable is at the base of the international society, for obvious reasons.
It is right to say that the realization of a right to self-determination should not entail the division or violation of territorial integrity and political unity of a sovereign and independent state. One has only to look at Chapter VII of Resolution 2625 and the Helsinki Final Act of 1975 to realize this: indeed all those instruments state that nothing in their wording must be interpreted as going against the integrity of the world’s states. Hence, only those secessions which have been approved by the central government are indeed accepted as legal by the international community: for example Montenegro’s and South Sudan’s independence have not been controversial.
Things are completely different with unilateral secessions are indeed regarded as dangerous and illegal by the majority of the international community and very few of them have been successful: Kosovo is still not recognised by the majority of the international community, while Georgia’s breakaway republics have been recognised only be a few countries.

From all of this it’s clear that Catalan secessionists would have a hard time if their dream of secession was to become true. With the central government not agreeing at any discussion of Spain’s unity, the separation of Catalonia would have to be unilateral and consequently illegal.
It will be illegal because the body of law on self-determination and the right to secession is very clear on its defence of the states’ territorial integrity when possible.
Of course there exists what has been termed as “remedial right” to secession, which peoples have when the state openly disrespect their rights and all other means of negotiation have failed. However this is not the case in Spain, where Catalans have right to a special regime of autonomy.
Finally the situation can be best summarized by quoting Judge Yusuf of the International Court of Justice when he said that there is no right of unilateral secession simply because a racially or ethnic distinct group wishes to do so.

BY: Alberto Pecoraro

Notes:

Cassese, A. 1998, Self-Determination of Peoples: A Legal Reappraisal, Cambridge University Press

Quane, H. 1998, The United Nations and the Evolving Right to Self-Determination, International Law Quarterly, Vol 47, N.3

Euronews, 11/09/2012, Thousands turn out to demand Catalan autonomy, available at http://www.euronews.com/2012/09/12/thousands-turn-out-to-demand-catalan-autonomy/ , accessed the 16/09/2012

ShareTweetShare
Previous Post

Another day another Lawsuit for Facebook

Next Post

Nick Clegg: No apologies, no suckers I'm not sorry...

Shout Out UK

Shout Out UK

Related Posts

Is Catalonia entitled to independence ?
Society

Maternity Leave: What really explains the gender pay gap

25/04/2018
Is Catalonia entitled to independence ?
Money

Why Do Financially Savvy People Avoid Going It Alone?

25/04/2018
Is Catalonia entitled to independence ?
Asia

Three million drug addicts in the Philippines: The real Narcos Netflix didn’t cover

24/04/2018
Is Catalonia entitled to independence ?
Money

Smart Ways To Grow Your Income Rapidly

24/04/2018
Is Catalonia entitled to independence ?
Law

Legal aid declines by 84% leaving the most vulnerable without justice

23/04/2018
Is Catalonia entitled to independence ?
Politics

Why the Commonwealth matters more than ever

20/04/2018
Next Post

Is Catalonia entitled to independence ?

Stay Connected

  • 13.7k Fans
  • 20.4k Followers
  • 105 Followers
  • 1.3k Subscribers
  • 3k Subscribers

Support Us

Support our work by becoming a Patron today!
Become a Patron!

Subscribe to our mailing list to receives daily updates direct to your inbox!

  • Trending
  • Comments
  • Latest
Is Catalonia entitled to independence ?

This Country is my country: Why is rural working-class Britain overlooked in the entertainment industry?

27/03/2018
Is Catalonia entitled to independence ?

Votes for 16s could rescue the Conservative Party

28/03/2018
Is Catalonia entitled to independence ?

Electoral fraud punishable by little more than a parking fine?

03/04/2018
Is Catalonia entitled to independence ?

‘Missing The Mark’: The Slim Shady of Advertising

09/04/2018
Is Catalonia entitled to independence ?

In my borough council, women earn almost 25% less than men

1
Is Catalonia entitled to independence ?

Cold War II: Will McCarthyism repeat itself or will we heed the past?

1
Is Catalonia entitled to independence ?

Democracy Dashboard: The missing piece British politics desperately needs

1
Is Catalonia entitled to independence ?

Votes for 16s could rescue the Conservative Party

1
Is Catalonia entitled to independence ?

Maternity Leave: What really explains the gender pay gap

25/04/2018
Is Catalonia entitled to independence ?

Why Do Financially Savvy People Avoid Going It Alone?

25/04/2018
Is Catalonia entitled to independence ?

Three million drug addicts in the Philippines: The real Narcos Netflix didn’t cover

24/04/2018
Is Catalonia entitled to independence ?

Smart Ways To Grow Your Income Rapidly

24/04/2018

Recent News

Is Catalonia entitled to independence ?

Maternity Leave: What really explains the gender pay gap

25/04/2018
Is Catalonia entitled to independence ?

Why Do Financially Savvy People Avoid Going It Alone?

25/04/2018
Is Catalonia entitled to independence ?

Three million drug addicts in the Philippines: The real Narcos Netflix didn’t cover

24/04/2018
Is Catalonia entitled to independence ?

Smart Ways To Grow Your Income Rapidly

24/04/2018
Load More
Shout Out UK

We are a multi-award winning independent youth news platform that provides young people with the tools necessary to engage in politics and a platform to shout out and be heard.

  • Advertising on Shout Out UK
  • Political Literacy Course
  • Editorial Guide
  • Legal
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms and Conditions

Subscribe to our mailing list to receives daily updates direct to your inbox!

  • About
  • Webmail
  • Our Team
  • Advertise
  • Legal
  • Contact Us

© 2018 ShoutOutUK LTD. or its affiliated companies. All rights reserved.

No Result
View All Result
  • Politics
    • Brexit 2016
    • Elections
    • GE2017
    • Law
  • World News
    • Africa
    • Asia
    • Australia
    • Europe
    • N. America
    • S. America
    • United Kingdom
  • Money
  • Culture, Travel and Sport
    • Environment
    • Health
    • Media
  • Reviews
  • Films
    • Homelessness
    • Anonymous
    • Youth Leaders
    • Mental Health
    • One in a Million
  • Political Literacy
    • Offline Course
    • Online Course
    • Election Pack
  • Get Involved
    • Write for us
    • Opportunities
    • Brexit Youth Check
    • Events

ShoutOutUK LTD. or its affiliated companies. All rights reserved.

Login to your account below

Forgotten Password?

Fill the forms bellow to register

All fields are required. Log In

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Log In