• Our Story
  • What We Do
  • Our Team
  • Legal
  • Contact Us
  • The Youth Leaders Debate
  • Anonymous: A Million Men
Write for Us
Shout Out UK
  • Politics
    • All
    • Brexit 2016
    • Elections
    • GE2017
    • Law
    Criticism of the Guardian is unfair. Who is really putting national security at risk?

    It’s panto season, but who’s who this election?

    Criticism of the Guardian is unfair. Who is really putting national security at risk?

    Disappearance of British GP practises

    Criticism of the Guardian is unfair. Who is really putting national security at risk?

    Labour’s Brexit cliff edge: The dangerous oblivion that’s taken hold

    Criticism of the Guardian is unfair. Who is really putting national security at risk?

    Three major party manifestos for the confused young voter

    Criticism of the Guardian is unfair. Who is really putting national security at risk?

    Mistakes To Avoid When Restoring A Historic Building

    Criticism of the Guardian is unfair. Who is really putting national security at risk?

    James Giles: An interview with the teenage election candidate

    Trending Tags

    • Young People
    • Women
    • Welfare
    • Theresa May
    • LabourConference2018
    • ConservativeConference2018
  • World News
    • All
    • Africa
    • Asia
    • Australia
    • Europe
    • N. America
    • S. America
    • United Kingdom
    Criticism of the Guardian is unfair. Who is really putting national security at risk?

    It’s panto season, but who’s who this election?

    Criticism of the Guardian is unfair. Who is really putting national security at risk?

    Disappearance of British GP practises

    Criticism of the Guardian is unfair. Who is really putting national security at risk?

    Labour’s Brexit cliff edge: The dangerous oblivion that’s taken hold

    Criticism of the Guardian is unfair. Who is really putting national security at risk?

    Sex workers aren’t going anywhere, so let’s stop demonising them

    Criticism of the Guardian is unfair. Who is really putting national security at risk?

    Three major party manifestos for the confused young voter

    Criticism of the Guardian is unfair. Who is really putting national security at risk?

    James Giles: An interview with the teenage election candidate

    Trending Tags

    • West
    • USA
    • Syria
    • US presidential election
    • Terrorism
  • Money
    • All
    • Business
    Criticism of the Guardian is unfair. Who is really putting national security at risk?

    New Year, New Car: Which Make And Model Is Right For You?

    Criticism of the Guardian is unfair. Who is really putting national security at risk?

    Supporting Local Businesses At Christmas

    Criticism of the Guardian is unfair. Who is really putting national security at risk?

    Does Following A Passion Make A Good Business?

    Criticism of the Guardian is unfair. Who is really putting national security at risk?

    How You Can Make More Of Your Home Business: Successful Tips To Get Your Biz Thriving

    Criticism of the Guardian is unfair. Who is really putting national security at risk?

    Britain’s Billionaires: Is it time to pay?

    Criticism of the Guardian is unfair. Who is really putting national security at risk?

    Every Business Needs An Office-Clearing Day

    Trending Tags

    • Advice
    • University
    • Unemployment
    • Technology
  • Culture, Travel and Sport
    • All
    • Environment
    • Health
    • Media
    Criticism of the Guardian is unfair. Who is really putting national security at risk?

    New Year, New Car: Which Make And Model Is Right For You?

    Criticism of the Guardian is unfair. Who is really putting national security at risk?

    Disappearance of British GP practises

    Criticism of the Guardian is unfair. Who is really putting national security at risk?

    Substance Abuse: Prevention Tips For Students

    Criticism of the Guardian is unfair. Who is really putting national security at risk?

    How You Can Make More Of Your Home Business: Successful Tips To Get Your Biz Thriving

    Criticism of the Guardian is unfair. Who is really putting national security at risk?

    Mistakes To Avoid When Restoring A Historic Building

    Criticism of the Guardian is unfair. Who is really putting national security at risk?

    Psychosomatic: A Big Word With Even Bigger Implications

    Trending Tags

    • Motorsport
    • Cars
    • Travel
    • Food
    • Music
  • Reviews
    Criticism of the Guardian is unfair. Who is really putting national security at risk?

    Review: Race Room Simulator

    Criticism of the Guardian is unfair. Who is really putting national security at risk?

    Knock Down the House: The women making America great

    Criticism of the Guardian is unfair. Who is really putting national security at risk?

    How The Favourite makes a refreshing change for queer women in film

    Criticism of the Guardian is unfair. Who is really putting national security at risk?

    Max Polyakov and Association Noosphere hold an engineering BestRoboFest 2018

    Criticism of the Guardian is unfair. Who is really putting national security at risk?

    Netflix’s Wild, Wild Country captures America’s ongoing xenophobia

  • Political Literacy Education Programmes
    • For Schools
    • For Individuals
  • Get Involved
    • Write for us
    • Opportunities
    • Events
No Result
View All Result
  • Politics
    • All
    • Brexit 2016
    • Elections
    • GE2017
    • Law
    Criticism of the Guardian is unfair. Who is really putting national security at risk?

    It’s panto season, but who’s who this election?

    Criticism of the Guardian is unfair. Who is really putting national security at risk?

    Disappearance of British GP practises

    Criticism of the Guardian is unfair. Who is really putting national security at risk?

    Labour’s Brexit cliff edge: The dangerous oblivion that’s taken hold

    Criticism of the Guardian is unfair. Who is really putting national security at risk?

    Three major party manifestos for the confused young voter

    Criticism of the Guardian is unfair. Who is really putting national security at risk?

    Mistakes To Avoid When Restoring A Historic Building

    Criticism of the Guardian is unfair. Who is really putting national security at risk?

    James Giles: An interview with the teenage election candidate

    Trending Tags

    • Young People
    • Women
    • Welfare
    • Theresa May
    • LabourConference2018
    • ConservativeConference2018
  • World News
    • All
    • Africa
    • Asia
    • Australia
    • Europe
    • N. America
    • S. America
    • United Kingdom
    Criticism of the Guardian is unfair. Who is really putting national security at risk?

    It’s panto season, but who’s who this election?

    Criticism of the Guardian is unfair. Who is really putting national security at risk?

    Disappearance of British GP practises

    Criticism of the Guardian is unfair. Who is really putting national security at risk?

    Labour’s Brexit cliff edge: The dangerous oblivion that’s taken hold

    Criticism of the Guardian is unfair. Who is really putting national security at risk?

    Sex workers aren’t going anywhere, so let’s stop demonising them

    Criticism of the Guardian is unfair. Who is really putting national security at risk?

    Three major party manifestos for the confused young voter

    Criticism of the Guardian is unfair. Who is really putting national security at risk?

    James Giles: An interview with the teenage election candidate

    Trending Tags

    • West
    • USA
    • Syria
    • US presidential election
    • Terrorism
  • Money
    • All
    • Business
    Criticism of the Guardian is unfair. Who is really putting national security at risk?

    New Year, New Car: Which Make And Model Is Right For You?

    Criticism of the Guardian is unfair. Who is really putting national security at risk?

    Supporting Local Businesses At Christmas

    Criticism of the Guardian is unfair. Who is really putting national security at risk?

    Does Following A Passion Make A Good Business?

    Criticism of the Guardian is unfair. Who is really putting national security at risk?

    How You Can Make More Of Your Home Business: Successful Tips To Get Your Biz Thriving

    Criticism of the Guardian is unfair. Who is really putting national security at risk?

    Britain’s Billionaires: Is it time to pay?

    Criticism of the Guardian is unfair. Who is really putting national security at risk?

    Every Business Needs An Office-Clearing Day

    Trending Tags

    • Advice
    • University
    • Unemployment
    • Technology
  • Culture, Travel and Sport
    • All
    • Environment
    • Health
    • Media
    Criticism of the Guardian is unfair. Who is really putting national security at risk?

    New Year, New Car: Which Make And Model Is Right For You?

    Criticism of the Guardian is unfair. Who is really putting national security at risk?

    Disappearance of British GP practises

    Criticism of the Guardian is unfair. Who is really putting national security at risk?

    Substance Abuse: Prevention Tips For Students

    Criticism of the Guardian is unfair. Who is really putting national security at risk?

    How You Can Make More Of Your Home Business: Successful Tips To Get Your Biz Thriving

    Criticism of the Guardian is unfair. Who is really putting national security at risk?

    Mistakes To Avoid When Restoring A Historic Building

    Criticism of the Guardian is unfair. Who is really putting national security at risk?

    Psychosomatic: A Big Word With Even Bigger Implications

    Trending Tags

    • Motorsport
    • Cars
    • Travel
    • Food
    • Music
  • Reviews
    Criticism of the Guardian is unfair. Who is really putting national security at risk?

    Review: Race Room Simulator

    Criticism of the Guardian is unfair. Who is really putting national security at risk?

    Knock Down the House: The women making America great

    Criticism of the Guardian is unfair. Who is really putting national security at risk?

    How The Favourite makes a refreshing change for queer women in film

    Criticism of the Guardian is unfair. Who is really putting national security at risk?

    Max Polyakov and Association Noosphere hold an engineering BestRoboFest 2018

    Criticism of the Guardian is unfair. Who is really putting national security at risk?

    Netflix’s Wild, Wild Country captures America’s ongoing xenophobia

  • Political Literacy Education Programmes
    • For Schools
    • For Individuals
  • Get Involved
    • Write for us
    • Opportunities
    • Events
No Result
View All Result
Shout Out UK
No Result
View All Result
Home Education

Criticism of the Guardian is unfair. Who is really putting national security at risk?

Nicholas Pentney by Nicholas Pentney
20/11/2013
0
Criticism of the Guardian is unfair. Who is really putting national security at risk?
0
SHARES
Share on FacebookShare on Twitter

Criticism of the Guardian is unfair. Who is really putting national security at risk?

The Guardian newspaper has been heavily criticised for publishing stories about mass surveillance based on the Snowden leaks.  The government led the charge, claiming that the Guardian’s stories had put national security at risk.  Defenders of the newspaper made the obvious and accurate counterclaim that the paper was acting in the national interest. Those defenders have missed an even more obvious counter-criticism: the government’s own lack of credibility when it comes to handling national security, i.e. who is the government to talk about putting our national security at risk? Hasn’t the actions of this government and especially its Labour predecessor done far more than the Guardian to damage national security?

Former Foreign Secretary Jack Straw was also critical. He said that the Guardian was: “indulgent and irresponsible.” Astoundingly, he spoke of “avoiding [another] 7th July 2005”. This is staggering because the London bombings were the tragic outcome of decisions made by the government that Straw himself was such a prominent member of.

Chatham House (Britain’s premier foreign affairs institution) conducted an investigation into 7/7. It concluded that: “The UK is at particular risk [of terrorist attacks] because it is the closest ally of the United States, has deployed armed forces in the military campaigns to topple the Taliban regime in Afghanistan and in Iraq.”  Blair and the rest of his government, rather ridiculously, tried to deny that their foreign policy had anything to do with 7/7. They said that the terrorists had struck because they “hate our freedoms.” That denial was made to look even more ridiculous when one of the captured 21/7 (the failed attack that took place two weeks after 7/7) attackers told authorities that his actions were directly inspired by UK foreign policy and military involvement in the Middle East.

7/7 and 21/7 are only two cases of many that starkly demonstrate how UK governments have put national security at risk. Since operations in Afghanistan began in 2001, the UK has been targeted many times: the 2006 transatlantic plot, the Haymarket bomb plot, Glasgow Airport and Exeter City Centre etc. More often than not, it was the perpetrators’ ineptitude rather than any thwarting by our intelligence agencies that saw relatively little harm done. By and large, these failed or ineffective attacks were low-tech and lacked sophistication (whilst still carrying the potential to be very lethal).  This is important to note in the context of the Snowden/Guardian criticism – i.e. the terrorist threat to the UK is of a nature that lacks complexity and planning and therefore extremely difficult (if not impossible) for intelligence agencies to intercept.

So who is the reckless party when it comes to national security? In the case of our governments, we have seen the tragic result of foreign policy decisions which were undertaken in the certain knowledge that they would heighten the risk to national security. To be fair to the present government, they did not undertake the initial foreign policy decisions. However, the foreign policy that they inherited and maintain does harm national security.

In the case of the Guardian, there is no such tragic evidence like 7/7 to suggest they have put national security at risk. Of course, it is way too early to really tell. However, the Guardian, unlike the Labour government, did not take its decision in the certain knowledge that it would harm national security. It should also be noted that the paper has been extremely careful in what it has made public. Also, let us not forget the nature of the threat we outlined earlier: terrorist attacks that are low-tech and lacking sophistication – the kind of threat that intelligence agencies find near-impossible to intercept. Finally, we must also remember that the paper does have a fundamental journalistic responsibility to let the UK population know what the state is up to.

Despite being at significant risk from terror for more than a decade, we are fortunate that more blood hasn’t been shed. On the whole, this hasn’t been down to good intelligence but rather the very bad (or rather, lack of) intelligence of the perpetrators involved. Miraculously, they continue to botch their attempts to inflict harm upon us. We can count ourselves lucky but we must be aware that one day our good fortune may run out. We can’t count on dumb luck and ever dumber terrorists indefinitely. Instead, we need tackle the roots of what threatens us; not give attention to things that are, at best, secondary such as the Guardian’s stories.

 

Nicholas Pentney

Tags: CorruptionCrimesInternet FreedomYoung People
ShareTweetShare
Previous Post

Does the UK need a Fat Tax? Dealing with Obesity in the UK

Next Post

Cannabis in Britain: Time to Legalise for Brits and the world?

Nicholas Pentney

Nicholas Pentney

Next Post
Criticism of the Guardian is unfair. Who is really putting national security at risk?

Cannabis in Britain: Time to Legalise for Brits and the world?

Stay Connected

  • 13.2k Fans
  • 12.8k Followers
  • 3.9k Followers
  • 1.7k Subscribers
  • 3k Subscribers

Subscribe to our mailing list to receives daily updates direct to your inbox!

  • Trending
  • Comments
  • Latest
Criticism of the Guardian is unfair. Who is really putting national security at risk?

Top 8 Brexit lies debunked

01/11/2019
Criticism of the Guardian is unfair. Who is really putting national security at risk?

England rugby’s private school problem

03/11/2019
Criticism of the Guardian is unfair. Who is really putting national security at risk?

Why Extinction Rebellion is close to extinction

28/10/2019
Criticism of the Guardian is unfair. Who is really putting national security at risk?

‘OK Boomer’ – Empowerment or Ageism?

18/11/2019
Criticism of the Guardian is unfair. Who is really putting national security at risk?

‘OK Boomer’ – Empowerment or Ageism?

2
Criticism of the Guardian is unfair. Who is really putting national security at risk?

Northern Ireland allows abortion and gay marriage by default

1
Criticism of the Guardian is unfair. Who is really putting national security at risk?

It’s panto season, but who’s who this election?

05/12/2019
Criticism of the Guardian is unfair. Who is really putting national security at risk?

New Year, New Car: Which Make And Model Is Right For You?

05/12/2019
Criticism of the Guardian is unfair. Who is really putting national security at risk?

Disappearance of British GP practises

05/12/2019
Criticism of the Guardian is unfair. Who is really putting national security at risk?

Labour’s Brexit cliff edge: The dangerous oblivion that’s taken hold

03/12/2019

Recent News

Criticism of the Guardian is unfair. Who is really putting national security at risk?

It’s panto season, but who’s who this election?

05/12/2019
Criticism of the Guardian is unfair. Who is really putting national security at risk?

New Year, New Car: Which Make And Model Is Right For You?

05/12/2019
Criticism of the Guardian is unfair. Who is really putting national security at risk?

Disappearance of British GP practises

05/12/2019
Criticism of the Guardian is unfair. Who is really putting national security at risk?

Labour’s Brexit cliff edge: The dangerous oblivion that’s taken hold

03/12/2019
Load More
Shout Out UK

We are a multi-award winning youth education brand that provides world class training and programmes on Political & Media literacy via our interactive platform.

  • Advertising on Shout Out UK
  • Political Literacy Programme
  • Editorial Guide
  • Legal
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms and Conditions

Subscribe to our mailing list to receives daily updates direct to your inbox!

  • About
  • Webmail
  • Our Team
  • Advertise
  • Legal
  • Contact Us

ShoutOutUK LTD. (company no. 09717655) or its affiliated companies. All rights reserved.

No Result
View All Result
  • Politics
  • World News
  • Money
  • Culture, Travel and Sport
  • Reviews
  • Political Literacy Programmes
    • For Schools
    • For Adults
    • Election Pack
    • EPlatform Login
  • Get Involved
    • Write for us
    • Opportunities
    • Events

ShoutOutUK LTD. (company no. 09717655) or its affiliated companies. All rights reserved.

Login to your account below

Forgotten Password?

Fill the forms bellow to register

All fields are required. Log In

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Log In
This website uses cookies to improve your experience. We'll assume you're ok with this, but you can opt-out if you wish. Accept Read More
Privacy & Cookies Policy

Privacy Overview

This website uses cookies to improve your experience while you navigate through the website. Out of these cookies, the cookies that are categorized as necessary are stored on your browser as they are essential for the working of basic functionalities of the website. We also use third-party cookies that help us analyze and understand how you use this website. These cookies will be stored in your browser only with your consent. You also have the option to opt-out of these cookies. But opting out of some of these cookies may have an effect on your browsing experience.
Privacy Overview

This website uses cookies to improve your experience while you navigate through the website. Out of these cookies, the cookies that are categorized as necessary are stored on your browser as they are essential for the working of basic functionalities of the website. We also use third-party cookies that help us analyze and understand how you use this website. These cookies will be stored in your browser only with your consent. You also have the option to opt-out of these cookies. But opting out of some of these cookies may have an effect on your browsing experience.

Necessary Always Enabled

Necessary cookies are absolutely essential for the website to function properly. This category only includes cookies that ensures basic functionalities and security features of the website. These cookies do not store any personal information.

Non-necessary

Any cookies that may not be particularly necessary for the website to function and is used specifically to collect user personal data via analytics, ads, other embedded contents are termed as non-necessary cookies. It is mandatory to procure user consent prior to running these cookies on your website.