• Our Story
  • What We Do
  • Our Team
  • Legal
  • Contact Us
  • The Youth Leaders Debate
  • Anonymous: A Million Men
Write for Us
Shout Out UK
  • Politics
    • All
    • Brexit 2016
    • Elections
    • GE2017
    • Law
    Why tribes are the ignored solution to the Middle East crisis

    Our response to the Daily Mail article regarding our work with Drillminister

    Why tribes are the ignored solution to the Middle East crisis

    The Conservatives’ ignoble warpath to victory

    Why tribes are the ignored solution to the Middle East crisis

    It’s panto season, but who’s who this election?

    Why tribes are the ignored solution to the Middle East crisis

    Disappearance of British GP practises

    Why tribes are the ignored solution to the Middle East crisis

    Labour’s Brexit cliff edge: The dangerous oblivion that’s taken hold

    Why tribes are the ignored solution to the Middle East crisis

    Three major party manifestos for the confused young voter

    Trending Tags

    • Young People
    • Women
    • Welfare
    • Theresa May
    • LabourConference2018
    • ConservativeConference2018
  • World News
    • All
    • Africa
    • Asia
    • Australia
    • Europe
    • N. America
    • S. America
    • United Kingdom
    Why tribes are the ignored solution to the Middle East crisis

    Our response to the Daily Mail article regarding our work with Drillminister

    Why tribes are the ignored solution to the Middle East crisis

    The Conservatives’ ignoble warpath to victory

    Why tribes are the ignored solution to the Middle East crisis

    It’s panto season, but who’s who this election?

    Why tribes are the ignored solution to the Middle East crisis

    Disappearance of British GP practises

    Why tribes are the ignored solution to the Middle East crisis

    Labour’s Brexit cliff edge: The dangerous oblivion that’s taken hold

    Why tribes are the ignored solution to the Middle East crisis

    Sex workers aren’t going anywhere, so let’s stop demonising them

    Trending Tags

    • West
    • USA
    • Syria
    • US presidential election
    • Terrorism
  • Money
    • All
    • Business
    Why tribes are the ignored solution to the Middle East crisis

    New Year, New Car: Which Make And Model Is Right For You?

    Why tribes are the ignored solution to the Middle East crisis

    Supporting Local Businesses At Christmas

    Why tribes are the ignored solution to the Middle East crisis

    Does Following A Passion Make A Good Business?

    Why tribes are the ignored solution to the Middle East crisis

    How You Can Make More Of Your Home Business: Successful Tips To Get Your Biz Thriving

    Why tribes are the ignored solution to the Middle East crisis

    Britain’s Billionaires: Is it time to pay?

    Why tribes are the ignored solution to the Middle East crisis

    Every Business Needs An Office-Clearing Day

    Trending Tags

    • Advice
    • University
    • Unemployment
    • Technology
  • Culture, Travel and Sport
    • All
    • Environment
    • Health
    • Media
    Why tribes are the ignored solution to the Middle East crisis

    New Year, New Car: Which Make And Model Is Right For You?

    Why tribes are the ignored solution to the Middle East crisis

    Disappearance of British GP practises

    Why tribes are the ignored solution to the Middle East crisis

    Substance Abuse: Prevention Tips For Students

    Why tribes are the ignored solution to the Middle East crisis

    How You Can Make More Of Your Home Business: Successful Tips To Get Your Biz Thriving

    Why tribes are the ignored solution to the Middle East crisis

    Mistakes To Avoid When Restoring A Historic Building

    Why tribes are the ignored solution to the Middle East crisis

    Psychosomatic: A Big Word With Even Bigger Implications

    Trending Tags

    • Motorsport
    • Cars
    • Travel
    • Food
    • Music
  • Reviews
    Why tribes are the ignored solution to the Middle East crisis

    Review: Race Room Simulator

    Why tribes are the ignored solution to the Middle East crisis

    Knock Down the House: The women making America great

    Why tribes are the ignored solution to the Middle East crisis

    How The Favourite makes a refreshing change for queer women in film

    Why tribes are the ignored solution to the Middle East crisis

    Max Polyakov and Association Noosphere hold an engineering BestRoboFest 2018

    Why tribes are the ignored solution to the Middle East crisis

    Netflix’s Wild, Wild Country captures America’s ongoing xenophobia

  • Political Literacy Education Programmes
    • For Schools
    • For Individuals
  • Get Involved
    • Write for us
    • Opportunities
    • Events
No Result
View All Result
  • Politics
    • All
    • Brexit 2016
    • Elections
    • GE2017
    • Law
    Why tribes are the ignored solution to the Middle East crisis

    Our response to the Daily Mail article regarding our work with Drillminister

    Why tribes are the ignored solution to the Middle East crisis

    The Conservatives’ ignoble warpath to victory

    Why tribes are the ignored solution to the Middle East crisis

    It’s panto season, but who’s who this election?

    Why tribes are the ignored solution to the Middle East crisis

    Disappearance of British GP practises

    Why tribes are the ignored solution to the Middle East crisis

    Labour’s Brexit cliff edge: The dangerous oblivion that’s taken hold

    Why tribes are the ignored solution to the Middle East crisis

    Three major party manifestos for the confused young voter

    Trending Tags

    • Young People
    • Women
    • Welfare
    • Theresa May
    • LabourConference2018
    • ConservativeConference2018
  • World News
    • All
    • Africa
    • Asia
    • Australia
    • Europe
    • N. America
    • S. America
    • United Kingdom
    Why tribes are the ignored solution to the Middle East crisis

    Our response to the Daily Mail article regarding our work with Drillminister

    Why tribes are the ignored solution to the Middle East crisis

    The Conservatives’ ignoble warpath to victory

    Why tribes are the ignored solution to the Middle East crisis

    It’s panto season, but who’s who this election?

    Why tribes are the ignored solution to the Middle East crisis

    Disappearance of British GP practises

    Why tribes are the ignored solution to the Middle East crisis

    Labour’s Brexit cliff edge: The dangerous oblivion that’s taken hold

    Why tribes are the ignored solution to the Middle East crisis

    Sex workers aren’t going anywhere, so let’s stop demonising them

    Trending Tags

    • West
    • USA
    • Syria
    • US presidential election
    • Terrorism
  • Money
    • All
    • Business
    Why tribes are the ignored solution to the Middle East crisis

    New Year, New Car: Which Make And Model Is Right For You?

    Why tribes are the ignored solution to the Middle East crisis

    Supporting Local Businesses At Christmas

    Why tribes are the ignored solution to the Middle East crisis

    Does Following A Passion Make A Good Business?

    Why tribes are the ignored solution to the Middle East crisis

    How You Can Make More Of Your Home Business: Successful Tips To Get Your Biz Thriving

    Why tribes are the ignored solution to the Middle East crisis

    Britain’s Billionaires: Is it time to pay?

    Why tribes are the ignored solution to the Middle East crisis

    Every Business Needs An Office-Clearing Day

    Trending Tags

    • Advice
    • University
    • Unemployment
    • Technology
  • Culture, Travel and Sport
    • All
    • Environment
    • Health
    • Media
    Why tribes are the ignored solution to the Middle East crisis

    New Year, New Car: Which Make And Model Is Right For You?

    Why tribes are the ignored solution to the Middle East crisis

    Disappearance of British GP practises

    Why tribes are the ignored solution to the Middle East crisis

    Substance Abuse: Prevention Tips For Students

    Why tribes are the ignored solution to the Middle East crisis

    How You Can Make More Of Your Home Business: Successful Tips To Get Your Biz Thriving

    Why tribes are the ignored solution to the Middle East crisis

    Mistakes To Avoid When Restoring A Historic Building

    Why tribes are the ignored solution to the Middle East crisis

    Psychosomatic: A Big Word With Even Bigger Implications

    Trending Tags

    • Motorsport
    • Cars
    • Travel
    • Food
    • Music
  • Reviews
    Why tribes are the ignored solution to the Middle East crisis

    Review: Race Room Simulator

    Why tribes are the ignored solution to the Middle East crisis

    Knock Down the House: The women making America great

    Why tribes are the ignored solution to the Middle East crisis

    How The Favourite makes a refreshing change for queer women in film

    Why tribes are the ignored solution to the Middle East crisis

    Max Polyakov and Association Noosphere hold an engineering BestRoboFest 2018

    Why tribes are the ignored solution to the Middle East crisis

    Netflix’s Wild, Wild Country captures America’s ongoing xenophobia

  • Political Literacy Education Programmes
    • For Schools
    • For Individuals
  • Get Involved
    • Write for us
    • Opportunities
    • Events
No Result
View All Result
Shout Out UK
No Result
View All Result
Home World News Africa

Why tribes are the ignored solution to the Middle East crisis

Stefano Marras by Stefano Marras
18/12/2017
0
Why tribes are the ignored solution to the Middle East crisis

Herat, July 2005 - Afghan peasant hand threshing in a field near the town

1
SHARES
Share on FacebookShare on Twitter

Since the fall of the Ottoman Empire and the end of colonialism, Middle East countries have adopted a Western-style political system, which for some of them led to instability and wars. The solution may lie in the tribal system …


 

In an interview with the editor of La Stampa, an Italian newspaper, Israeli scholar Mordechai Kedar argued that to reach peace and stability in the Middle East, tribal states should return. In his view in fact, tribes are the most suitable and proper type of political organization for many countries of the region. The nation-state instead, as a political institution originated in Europe, which partly substituted the tribes, has proved to be inefficient for many of those countries. The only exceptions, according to Kedar, seem to be the Gulf states, because of the presence of only one dominant tribe, which helped to form homogeneous and stable nations.

On the other hand, countries like Afghanistan, Libya and Yemen where there are dozens of tribes, each one with its own army and territory, have been kept united only through dictatorship. However, this did not prove to be either right nor functional. The Arab Spring and the fall of Gheddafi showed how fragile those regimes were, urging critical rethinking of which political system is more fitting for them.

Accordingly, the international community should consider more critically the tribes’ role; not necessarily as something outdated and backward, but as a cultural institution, born out of specific historical and geographical circumstances which for centuries have represented a coherent and stabilizing element in those societies.

Some progress has already been made. For instance, in April 2017 the Italian government signed up to an agreement with the two main southern Libyan tribes, the Tebu and the Awlad Suleiman, to stop migrants reaching Mediterranean shores as well as to end the hostilities between them in the area. The two tribes have been in conflict since the fall of Gheddafi, and therefore this reconciliation represented an important step towards a more stable and united Libya. But more needs to be done. There are dozens of tribes which cannot be ignored and the Libyan case is not the only one.

In Syria, Yemen and Afghanistan, for example, recognising the importance of tribes is now more crucial than ever. These countries have been experiencing a tragic civil war and foreign military interventions, placing under question the role of tribes and states. In Yemen, tribes have always been a cornerstone of the country, and where a state is lacking or absent, they fill the gap bringing order and stability. Their role is therefore essential not only for understanding and solving the ongoing civil war, but also for building a more stable and prosperous country afterwards.

On the other hand, in Syria, tribes have not traditionally had as much importance as in Libya and Yemen. However, as the civil war weakened the state’s power their importance has increased once again, showing them to be indispensable players in the country’s political and social structure — especially in the eastern region.

Finally, in Afghanistan, despite all the attempts for over a hundred years to build a united and centralized nation-state, tribal organization still plays an important and vital role, restraining the power of the state.

All in all, these cases  show that tribes are still powerful and integral elements in these societies, but less so in politics.  Consequently, they should be given more political importance, integrating them into the existing institutions.

Columbia University scholar Daniel Corstange said that tribes are:

‘the second-best substitutes for an absent or weak state’.

Any change in the institutional framework, however, has to come from within, and not from foreign powers. Still, the international community might help in this process by giving them more relevance and respect.

 

 

 

Share1TweetShare
Previous Post

Grenfell Tower: a Sordid Affair

Next Post

The Millennial Railcard: A farce that won't save young people much money

Stefano Marras

Stefano Marras

Next Post
Why tribes are the ignored solution to the Middle East crisis

The Millennial Railcard: A farce that won't save young people much money

Stay Connected

  • 13.2k Fans
  • 12.8k Followers
  • 4.1k Followers
  • 1.7k Subscribers
  • 3k Subscribers

Subscribe to our mailing list to receives daily updates direct to your inbox!

  • Trending
  • Comments
  • Latest
Why tribes are the ignored solution to the Middle East crisis

Top 8 Brexit lies debunked

01/11/2019
Why tribes are the ignored solution to the Middle East crisis

England rugby’s private school problem

03/11/2019
Why tribes are the ignored solution to the Middle East crisis

Why Extinction Rebellion is close to extinction

28/10/2019
Why tribes are the ignored solution to the Middle East crisis

‘OK Boomer’ – Empowerment or Ageism?

18/11/2019
Why tribes are the ignored solution to the Middle East crisis

‘OK Boomer’ – Empowerment or Ageism?

2
Why tribes are the ignored solution to the Middle East crisis

Northern Ireland allows abortion and gay marriage by default

1
Why tribes are the ignored solution to the Middle East crisis

Our response to the Daily Mail article regarding our work with Drillminister

09/12/2019
Why tribes are the ignored solution to the Middle East crisis

The Conservatives’ ignoble warpath to victory

09/12/2019
Why tribes are the ignored solution to the Middle East crisis

It’s panto season, but who’s who this election?

05/12/2019
Why tribes are the ignored solution to the Middle East crisis

New Year, New Car: Which Make And Model Is Right For You?

05/12/2019

Recent News

Why tribes are the ignored solution to the Middle East crisis

Our response to the Daily Mail article regarding our work with Drillminister

09/12/2019
Why tribes are the ignored solution to the Middle East crisis

The Conservatives’ ignoble warpath to victory

09/12/2019
Why tribes are the ignored solution to the Middle East crisis

It’s panto season, but who’s who this election?

05/12/2019
Why tribes are the ignored solution to the Middle East crisis

New Year, New Car: Which Make And Model Is Right For You?

05/12/2019
Load More
Shout Out UK

We are a multi-award winning youth education brand that provides world class training and programmes on Political & Media literacy via our interactive platform.

  • Advertising on Shout Out UK
  • Political Literacy Programme
  • Editorial Guide
  • Legal
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms and Conditions

Subscribe to our mailing list to receives daily updates direct to your inbox!

  • About
  • Webmail
  • Our Team
  • Advertise
  • Legal
  • Contact Us

ShoutOutUK LTD. (company no. 09717655) or its affiliated companies. All rights reserved.

No Result
View All Result
  • Politics
  • World News
  • Money
  • Culture, Travel and Sport
  • Reviews
  • Political Literacy Programmes
    • For Schools
    • For Adults
    • Election Pack
    • EPlatform Login
  • Get Involved
    • Write for us
    • Opportunities
    • Events

ShoutOutUK LTD. (company no. 09717655) or its affiliated companies. All rights reserved.

Login to your account below

Forgotten Password?

Fill the forms bellow to register

All fields are required. Log In

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Log In
This website uses cookies to improve your experience. We'll assume you're ok with this, but you can opt-out if you wish. Accept Read More
Privacy & Cookies Policy

Privacy Overview

This website uses cookies to improve your experience while you navigate through the website. Out of these cookies, the cookies that are categorized as necessary are stored on your browser as they are essential for the working of basic functionalities of the website. We also use third-party cookies that help us analyze and understand how you use this website. These cookies will be stored in your browser only with your consent. You also have the option to opt-out of these cookies. But opting out of some of these cookies may have an effect on your browsing experience.
Privacy Overview

This website uses cookies to improve your experience while you navigate through the website. Out of these cookies, the cookies that are categorized as necessary are stored on your browser as they are essential for the working of basic functionalities of the website. We also use third-party cookies that help us analyze and understand how you use this website. These cookies will be stored in your browser only with your consent. You also have the option to opt-out of these cookies. But opting out of some of these cookies may have an effect on your browsing experience.

Necessary Always Enabled

Necessary cookies are absolutely essential for the website to function properly. This category only includes cookies that ensures basic functionalities and security features of the website. These cookies do not store any personal information.

Non-necessary

Any cookies that may not be particularly necessary for the website to function and is used specifically to collect user personal data via analytics, ads, other embedded contents are termed as non-necessary cookies. It is mandatory to procure user consent prior to running these cookies on your website.