• Our Story
  • What We Do
  • Our Team
  • Legal
  • Contact Us
  • The Youth Leaders Debate
  • Anonymous: A Million Men
Write for Us
Shout Out UK
  • Politics
    • All
    • Brexit 2016
    • Elections
    • GE2017
    • Law
    The perversity of ‘reverse Apartheid’ in South Africa

    It’s panto season, but who’s who this election?

    The perversity of ‘reverse Apartheid’ in South Africa

    Disappearance of British GP practises

    The perversity of ‘reverse Apartheid’ in South Africa

    Labour’s Brexit cliff edge: The dangerous oblivion that’s taken hold

    The perversity of ‘reverse Apartheid’ in South Africa

    Three major party manifestos for the confused young voter

    The perversity of ‘reverse Apartheid’ in South Africa

    Mistakes To Avoid When Restoring A Historic Building

    The perversity of ‘reverse Apartheid’ in South Africa

    James Giles: An interview with the teenage election candidate

    Trending Tags

    • Young People
    • Women
    • Welfare
    • Theresa May
    • LabourConference2018
    • ConservativeConference2018
  • World News
    • All
    • Africa
    • Asia
    • Australia
    • Europe
    • N. America
    • S. America
    • United Kingdom
    The perversity of ‘reverse Apartheid’ in South Africa

    It’s panto season, but who’s who this election?

    The perversity of ‘reverse Apartheid’ in South Africa

    Disappearance of British GP practises

    The perversity of ‘reverse Apartheid’ in South Africa

    Labour’s Brexit cliff edge: The dangerous oblivion that’s taken hold

    The perversity of ‘reverse Apartheid’ in South Africa

    Sex workers aren’t going anywhere, so let’s stop demonising them

    The perversity of ‘reverse Apartheid’ in South Africa

    Three major party manifestos for the confused young voter

    The perversity of ‘reverse Apartheid’ in South Africa

    James Giles: An interview with the teenage election candidate

    Trending Tags

    • West
    • USA
    • Syria
    • US presidential election
    • Terrorism
  • Money
    • All
    • Business
    The perversity of ‘reverse Apartheid’ in South Africa

    New Year, New Car: Which Make And Model Is Right For You?

    The perversity of ‘reverse Apartheid’ in South Africa

    Supporting Local Businesses At Christmas

    The perversity of ‘reverse Apartheid’ in South Africa

    Does Following A Passion Make A Good Business?

    The perversity of ‘reverse Apartheid’ in South Africa

    How You Can Make More Of Your Home Business: Successful Tips To Get Your Biz Thriving

    The perversity of ‘reverse Apartheid’ in South Africa

    Britain’s Billionaires: Is it time to pay?

    The perversity of ‘reverse Apartheid’ in South Africa

    Every Business Needs An Office-Clearing Day

    Trending Tags

    • Advice
    • University
    • Unemployment
    • Technology
  • Culture, Travel and Sport
    • All
    • Environment
    • Health
    • Media
    The perversity of ‘reverse Apartheid’ in South Africa

    New Year, New Car: Which Make And Model Is Right For You?

    The perversity of ‘reverse Apartheid’ in South Africa

    Disappearance of British GP practises

    The perversity of ‘reverse Apartheid’ in South Africa

    Substance Abuse: Prevention Tips For Students

    The perversity of ‘reverse Apartheid’ in South Africa

    How You Can Make More Of Your Home Business: Successful Tips To Get Your Biz Thriving

    The perversity of ‘reverse Apartheid’ in South Africa

    Mistakes To Avoid When Restoring A Historic Building

    The perversity of ‘reverse Apartheid’ in South Africa

    Psychosomatic: A Big Word With Even Bigger Implications

    Trending Tags

    • Motorsport
    • Cars
    • Travel
    • Food
    • Music
  • Reviews
    The perversity of ‘reverse Apartheid’ in South Africa

    Review: Race Room Simulator

    The perversity of ‘reverse Apartheid’ in South Africa

    Knock Down the House: The women making America great

    The perversity of ‘reverse Apartheid’ in South Africa

    How The Favourite makes a refreshing change for queer women in film

    The perversity of ‘reverse Apartheid’ in South Africa

    Max Polyakov and Association Noosphere hold an engineering BestRoboFest 2018

    The perversity of ‘reverse Apartheid’ in South Africa

    Netflix’s Wild, Wild Country captures America’s ongoing xenophobia

  • Political Literacy Education Programmes
    • For Schools
    • For Individuals
  • Get Involved
    • Write for us
    • Opportunities
    • Events
No Result
View All Result
  • Politics
    • All
    • Brexit 2016
    • Elections
    • GE2017
    • Law
    The perversity of ‘reverse Apartheid’ in South Africa

    It’s panto season, but who’s who this election?

    The perversity of ‘reverse Apartheid’ in South Africa

    Disappearance of British GP practises

    The perversity of ‘reverse Apartheid’ in South Africa

    Labour’s Brexit cliff edge: The dangerous oblivion that’s taken hold

    The perversity of ‘reverse Apartheid’ in South Africa

    Three major party manifestos for the confused young voter

    The perversity of ‘reverse Apartheid’ in South Africa

    Mistakes To Avoid When Restoring A Historic Building

    The perversity of ‘reverse Apartheid’ in South Africa

    James Giles: An interview with the teenage election candidate

    Trending Tags

    • Young People
    • Women
    • Welfare
    • Theresa May
    • LabourConference2018
    • ConservativeConference2018
  • World News
    • All
    • Africa
    • Asia
    • Australia
    • Europe
    • N. America
    • S. America
    • United Kingdom
    The perversity of ‘reverse Apartheid’ in South Africa

    It’s panto season, but who’s who this election?

    The perversity of ‘reverse Apartheid’ in South Africa

    Disappearance of British GP practises

    The perversity of ‘reverse Apartheid’ in South Africa

    Labour’s Brexit cliff edge: The dangerous oblivion that’s taken hold

    The perversity of ‘reverse Apartheid’ in South Africa

    Sex workers aren’t going anywhere, so let’s stop demonising them

    The perversity of ‘reverse Apartheid’ in South Africa

    Three major party manifestos for the confused young voter

    The perversity of ‘reverse Apartheid’ in South Africa

    James Giles: An interview with the teenage election candidate

    Trending Tags

    • West
    • USA
    • Syria
    • US presidential election
    • Terrorism
  • Money
    • All
    • Business
    The perversity of ‘reverse Apartheid’ in South Africa

    New Year, New Car: Which Make And Model Is Right For You?

    The perversity of ‘reverse Apartheid’ in South Africa

    Supporting Local Businesses At Christmas

    The perversity of ‘reverse Apartheid’ in South Africa

    Does Following A Passion Make A Good Business?

    The perversity of ‘reverse Apartheid’ in South Africa

    How You Can Make More Of Your Home Business: Successful Tips To Get Your Biz Thriving

    The perversity of ‘reverse Apartheid’ in South Africa

    Britain’s Billionaires: Is it time to pay?

    The perversity of ‘reverse Apartheid’ in South Africa

    Every Business Needs An Office-Clearing Day

    Trending Tags

    • Advice
    • University
    • Unemployment
    • Technology
  • Culture, Travel and Sport
    • All
    • Environment
    • Health
    • Media
    The perversity of ‘reverse Apartheid’ in South Africa

    New Year, New Car: Which Make And Model Is Right For You?

    The perversity of ‘reverse Apartheid’ in South Africa

    Disappearance of British GP practises

    The perversity of ‘reverse Apartheid’ in South Africa

    Substance Abuse: Prevention Tips For Students

    The perversity of ‘reverse Apartheid’ in South Africa

    How You Can Make More Of Your Home Business: Successful Tips To Get Your Biz Thriving

    The perversity of ‘reverse Apartheid’ in South Africa

    Mistakes To Avoid When Restoring A Historic Building

    The perversity of ‘reverse Apartheid’ in South Africa

    Psychosomatic: A Big Word With Even Bigger Implications

    Trending Tags

    • Motorsport
    • Cars
    • Travel
    • Food
    • Music
  • Reviews
    The perversity of ‘reverse Apartheid’ in South Africa

    Review: Race Room Simulator

    The perversity of ‘reverse Apartheid’ in South Africa

    Knock Down the House: The women making America great

    The perversity of ‘reverse Apartheid’ in South Africa

    How The Favourite makes a refreshing change for queer women in film

    The perversity of ‘reverse Apartheid’ in South Africa

    Max Polyakov and Association Noosphere hold an engineering BestRoboFest 2018

    The perversity of ‘reverse Apartheid’ in South Africa

    Netflix’s Wild, Wild Country captures America’s ongoing xenophobia

  • Political Literacy Education Programmes
    • For Schools
    • For Individuals
  • Get Involved
    • Write for us
    • Opportunities
    • Events
No Result
View All Result
Shout Out UK
No Result
View All Result
Home World News Africa

The perversity of ‘reverse Apartheid’ in South Africa

‘Black Economic Empowerment’ imposes a blatantly racist hierarchy, and it is the country’s Indian population who are worst off

Shannon Rawlins by Shannon Rawlins
09/09/2018
0
The perversity of ‘reverse Apartheid’ in South Africa
92
SHARES
Share on FacebookShare on Twitter

Have you heard of Black Economic Empowerment? Probably not. Me neither until last week, when I met Ca’reen Johnson Govindasamy, a woman of Indian heritage who lives in South Africa. When I asked her about the political situation in her country, she looked round furtively, said ‘sorry if I’m being racist but …’ and then proceeded to tell me about the discrimination and injustice which she, other Indians and the white population of South Africa have to suffer, due to this policy.


Ca’reen was not being racist — in fact quite the opposite. She was raising a very valid criticism of the racism which permeates everyday life in South Africa.

Black Economic Empowerment refers to a post-Apartheid policy aimed at opening up opportunities for South Africa’s black population. It imposes quotas to ensure black South Africans are appropriately represented in both the public and private sector — the intention, of course, being to rectify the damage caused by Apartheid.

Instead however, it has caused a genuine increase in poverty among South Africa’s white and Indian population. And since Cyril Ramaphosa came to power in February, the situation has only got worse, with a very distinct hierarchy having emerged.

No one can deny that the horrors of the Apartheid era were just that: horrific. Nor can anyone draw a valid parallel between the racism in South Africa during the mid-twentieth century and the racism there today. But neither of these things mean we can vindicate awarding people opportunities and rights purely on the basis of the colour of their skin.

I have spoken to Ca’reen to investigate this veiled discrimination which has become the norm in South Africa.

What is the racial hierarchy in South Africa like?

She talked about four distinct races into which people are pigeonholed in South Africa: native black people, white people, Indian people and coloured people (mixed race). She described Indians as being ‘in between’.

How can a racial hierarchy of any description — regardless of who is at the bottom and who is at the top — be justified?

South Africa in fact has the biggest Indian population outside of India, something which many people don’t realise. But they are not a valued group in South African society, and according to Ca’reen, many ‘don’t see Indians as true South Africans’.

How do the discriminatory policies affect you?

Ca’reen told me simply and bluntly that if she is ‘in competition with a black person, they have preference’. Indians are an extremely hardworking group of people, yet they have nothing to show for their efforts — solely ‘because of the colour they were born’.

Naturally, I wondered why on earth companies in South Africa comply with this, and she explained to me that ‘businesses pay less tax according to how many BEE (Black Economic Empowerment) points they have. Hiring a black person has the highest points … Indians are in the middle again’.

I was shocked. For one, this is detrimental for the South African economy; production levels obviously fall, because incentive is stifled and meritocracy is compromised. But it also carries echoes of the sorts of policies in place during the Apartheid epoch — as Ca’reen put it, a ‘mirror image’.

How are Indians perceived in South Africa?

She told me that the black population of South Africa (the vast majority, at 76 per cent) ‘feel like we are stealing from them and that we should go back to India’. Once a colonised people — like the native South Africans — Indians have experienced their fair share of oppression and discrimination. This makes their predicament even more unjust, and it has left them feeling ostracised and bitter.

Ca’reen said: ‘I was born in South Africa, so were my grandparents and great grandparents and so forth’. Yet in spite of this, she is still not considered to be a true South African.

South Africa has such a large Indian population because when it was a British colony, the UK authorities sent Indians there to work on the sugar plantations; they are victims of imperialism too. So why, then, should they have to be pawns in the social power struggle between black and white South Africans?

Would you describe it as positive discrimination or another form of racism?

Ca’reen considers Black Economic Empowerment to be racism, pure and simple. She said ‘if you study and work for many years for your degree and someone who has no education receives the job just because of the colour of they were born, [this] is completely unfair and unjust’.

She is right. It can hardly be denied. Perhaps a parallel can be drawn with the recent polemic over diversity in Oxbridge. The reason some Cambridge colleges didn’t accept any black students last year wasn’t because they perceive white people to be superior, but because the white people happened to have better grades, better personal statements and better interview skills. So why should those better candidates lose out? The same applies to the situation in South Africa.

Yes, opening up opportunities for black people is important, but this should not be at the expense of the rights of white people, or Indian people, or Jewish people, or Chinese people, or Hawaiian people.

So why does no one speak out about this?

Ca’reen’s answer to this question was telling. She said ‘people don’t speak about it because we are indoctrinated … that policy was put in place to reverse the past’. But does the past need to be reversed? And has this reversal already gone too far in the opposite direction?

And perhaps the fact that no one in this country is aware of the reality in South Africa tells us something about the problem with our own attitudes. I’ll leave you to work that one out.

Tags: ApartheidIndiansracismsouth Africa
Share92TweetShare
Previous Post

Football Holiday: Where To Go In Europe

Next Post

Why are students from Northern Ireland denied crucial postgraduate funding?

Shannon Rawlins

Shannon Rawlins

Young political commentator from Kent - interested in British politics and youth issues

Next Post
The perversity of ‘reverse Apartheid’ in South Africa

Why are students from Northern Ireland denied crucial postgraduate funding?

Stay Connected

  • 13.2k Fans
  • 12.8k Followers
  • 3.9k Followers
  • 1.7k Subscribers
  • 3k Subscribers

Subscribe to our mailing list to receives daily updates direct to your inbox!

  • Trending
  • Comments
  • Latest
The perversity of ‘reverse Apartheid’ in South Africa

Top 8 Brexit lies debunked

01/11/2019
The perversity of ‘reverse Apartheid’ in South Africa

CBD Oil UK: An Introduction

06/10/2019
The perversity of ‘reverse Apartheid’ in South Africa

England rugby’s private school problem

03/11/2019
The perversity of ‘reverse Apartheid’ in South Africa

Why Extinction Rebellion is close to extinction

28/10/2019
The perversity of ‘reverse Apartheid’ in South Africa

‘OK Boomer’ – Empowerment or Ageism?

2
The perversity of ‘reverse Apartheid’ in South Africa

Northern Ireland allows abortion and gay marriage by default

1
The perversity of ‘reverse Apartheid’ in South Africa

It’s panto season, but who’s who this election?

05/12/2019
The perversity of ‘reverse Apartheid’ in South Africa

New Year, New Car: Which Make And Model Is Right For You?

05/12/2019
The perversity of ‘reverse Apartheid’ in South Africa

Disappearance of British GP practises

05/12/2019
The perversity of ‘reverse Apartheid’ in South Africa

Labour’s Brexit cliff edge: The dangerous oblivion that’s taken hold

03/12/2019

Recent News

The perversity of ‘reverse Apartheid’ in South Africa

It’s panto season, but who’s who this election?

05/12/2019
The perversity of ‘reverse Apartheid’ in South Africa

New Year, New Car: Which Make And Model Is Right For You?

05/12/2019
The perversity of ‘reverse Apartheid’ in South Africa

Disappearance of British GP practises

05/12/2019
The perversity of ‘reverse Apartheid’ in South Africa

Labour’s Brexit cliff edge: The dangerous oblivion that’s taken hold

03/12/2019
Load More
Shout Out UK

We are a multi-award winning youth education brand that provides world class training and programmes on Political & Media literacy via our interactive platform.

  • Advertising on Shout Out UK
  • Political Literacy Programme
  • Editorial Guide
  • Legal
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms and Conditions

Subscribe to our mailing list to receives daily updates direct to your inbox!

  • About
  • Webmail
  • Our Team
  • Advertise
  • Legal
  • Contact Us

ShoutOutUK LTD. (company no. 09717655) or its affiliated companies. All rights reserved.

No Result
View All Result
  • Politics
  • World News
  • Money
  • Culture, Travel and Sport
  • Reviews
  • Political Literacy Programmes
    • For Schools
    • For Adults
    • Election Pack
    • EPlatform Login
  • Get Involved
    • Write for us
    • Opportunities
    • Events

ShoutOutUK LTD. (company no. 09717655) or its affiliated companies. All rights reserved.

Login to your account below

Forgotten Password?

Fill the forms bellow to register

All fields are required. Log In

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Log In
This website uses cookies to improve your experience. We'll assume you're ok with this, but you can opt-out if you wish. Accept Read More
Privacy & Cookies Policy

Privacy Overview

This website uses cookies to improve your experience while you navigate through the website. Out of these cookies, the cookies that are categorized as necessary are stored on your browser as they are essential for the working of basic functionalities of the website. We also use third-party cookies that help us analyze and understand how you use this website. These cookies will be stored in your browser only with your consent. You also have the option to opt-out of these cookies. But opting out of some of these cookies may have an effect on your browsing experience.
Privacy Overview

This website uses cookies to improve your experience while you navigate through the website. Out of these cookies, the cookies that are categorized as necessary are stored on your browser as they are essential for the working of basic functionalities of the website. We also use third-party cookies that help us analyze and understand how you use this website. These cookies will be stored in your browser only with your consent. You also have the option to opt-out of these cookies. But opting out of some of these cookies may have an effect on your browsing experience.

Necessary Always Enabled

Necessary cookies are absolutely essential for the website to function properly. This category only includes cookies that ensures basic functionalities and security features of the website. These cookies do not store any personal information.

Non-necessary

Any cookies that may not be particularly necessary for the website to function and is used specifically to collect user personal data via analytics, ads, other embedded contents are termed as non-necessary cookies. It is mandatory to procure user consent prior to running these cookies on your website.